Interviewing the Applicants – Who Chose Who?
At its April 23, 2019 City Council meeting, the City Council approved the following process for identifying an individual for appointment to the existing City Council vacancy (by a vote of 3-1, Councilmember Fox opposed):
- Following the application submission deadline, each Councilmember will choose up to four applicants to interview.
- The order of interviews will be determined by random selection (conducted by City Clerk in a public setting). The City Clerk will draw names and schedule interviews in that order.
- Each candidate/applicant will be allowed 15 minutes total, which includes their presentation and a City Council question and answer period. Phone interviews will be permitted for those who cannot attend in person. Each interviewee will be asked not to enter the Council Chamber until their scheduled interview.
- Following the interviews, each Councilmember will choose 2 to 3 finalists, which the City Clerk will list based on a random process and at which time the City Council will consider each of the finalists in order until a majority vote is reached.
Interview schedule for Tuesday, May 14:
|12:05 p.m.||Chen, Gang||R||Shea|
|12:20 p.m.||Kang, Sukhee||D||Khan|
|12:35 p.m.||Owens, Rachel||R||Kuo|
|12:50 p.m.||O’Malley, Caroline “Carrie”||R||Shea|
|1:05 p.m.||Carroll, Michael C.||R||Kuo|
|1:20 p.m.||Ehrlich, David C.||R||Kuo|
|1:35 p.m.||Hansen, Scott Robert||D||Khan|
|1:50 p.m.||Johnson-Norris, Lauren||D||Fox|
|2:05 p.m.||Metz, Conrad William||R||Kuo|
|2:20 p.m.||Stein, Russell||NPP||Shea|
|2:35 p.m.||Smith, Greg||R||Shea|
|2:50 p.m||Khamsi-Farivar, Shiva||D||Khan|
Here is a list of which Councilmember selected which applicants:
David C. Ehrlich
Rachel A. Owens
Michael C. Carroll
Conrad W. Metz
Additional Information and Procedures
(Per the City Council agenda)
31 applications were submitted to the City Clerk by the May 3, 2019 application deadline. Those applications were then forwarded to the City Council for review. On May 8, 2019, each Councilmember provided up to four applicants that would move forward in the interview process following which the City Clerk, in the Council Chamber, randomly called the selected applicants to schedule interviews to take place during the special City Council meeting on May 14, 2019 from
12 to 4 p.m. (Attachment 1).
Each applicant will be allowed fifteen minutes in which to give a presentation that will include a question and answer period. The City Clerk will be timing the applicant interviews to ensure a fair and transparent process.
Following the interviews, and time permitting, the City Council will move into the discussion and deliberation portion of the meeting. Following the special meeting, the May 14, 2019 regular City Council meeting will convene at 4 p.m., with continued deliberations to be held during Agenda Item No. 5.2. At that time, each City Councilmember may offer 2 to 3 finalists for final review.
The order of consideration of finalists will be based on a random selection process conducted by the City Clerk. Each candidate will be considered in order until a majority vote is reached.
If the City Council is not able to make an appointment at the May 14, 2019 regular City Council meeting, the item could be continued to the meeting of May 28, 2019 allowing for further review and consideration of qualified applicants. The deadline for appointment by the City Council is June 3, 2019. If no appointment is made by the June 3, 2019, the City Council is required by the Irvine Municipal Code to call a special election to fill the vacancy.
The interviews will be public and broadcast on ICTV.
For the list of interview times memo from city clerk click HERE.
For the May 14th City Council Agenda click HERE.
Susan SayreMay 13, 2019 at 4:09 pm
You can see from the list of selected applicants submitted by the City Council members that the selection process is a SHAM. I am astounded by the number of applicants with great potential that were not selected by any of the City Council members. It is clear to me that there is no intention for the City Council to reach a majority vote and thereby forcing a special election.
Comments are closed.